Buffalo News Logo.jpg

What the dying dream about, and why a Buffalo doctor wants the world to listen

When Dr. Christopher Kerr and his research team at Hospice & Palliative Care Buffalo began studying the end-of-life experiences of their patients, the work was intended to convince skeptical doctors that they should recognize predeath visions and dreams as medically important to improve the care provided to the dying.

But after years of research, interviews with more than 1,400 patients and a published book, many of Kerr’s fellow physicians remained uninterested.

Kerr’s findings, however, seeped out and reached an even wider audience. Since his TEDx talk in Buffalo in 2015, Kerr has been interviewed by The New York Times, The Washington Post, Oprah Winfrey for The Oprah Podcast and, just recently, by Steven Bartlett for the popular podcast, The Diary of a CEO.

For more than a decade now, the work has fascinated people across the world. The research resonates with the public because it validates what so many family members and friends have observed at the bedside of a dying loved one: powerful dreams and visions capable of bringing comfort and meaning to the dying process.

As Kerr’s team found, patients often experience an increase in the frequency of dreams and visions, while asleep or awake, as they approach the end of life. These end-of-life experiences – a term used because of the vivid nature of the experiences, which feel real to the patient – commonly feature deceased or living loved ones, preparations to travel somewhere, pets or animals, religious figures and past meaningful experiences.

Some experiences can be distressing, but more of them bring a sense of comfort. As Kerr writes in his 2020 book, “Death Is But a Dream,” end-of-life experiences “are centered on personal histories, self-understanding, concrete relationships and singular events.” In these experiences, Kerr writes, “long-lost loved ones come back to reassure; past wounds are healed; loose ends are tied; lifelong conflicts are revisited; forgiveness is achieved.”

“I think the ones that stand out, for me, are the people who’ve been harmed or injured or broken, and those kinds of psychic wounds get addressed at the end,” Kerr told The Buffalo News. “The veterans who have survivor’s guilt; loss of a loved one, particularly a child. That sort of inherent healing is pretty bizarre or moving to witness.”

Kerr, CEO and chief medical officer of Hospice & Palliative Care Buffalo, said his journey into end-of-life experiences was not planned. In some ways, however, his connection to the work can be traced to the last day he spent with his father more than 50 years ago.

A powerful moment as a child

Kerr was 12 years old when he last saw his father.

That day in the hospital, his father fiddled with the buttons on his son’s jacket, telling Kerr to get ready because he was going to take him fishing at their cottage in Canada.

The young Kerr knew that whatever his father was experiencing in that moment was bringing him peace and comfort. A priest there that day told Kerr that his father was “delusional,” Kerr wrote in his book.

His father died later that night, but the moment stuck with him.

“That was my last time I saw him, and truthfully, it kind of haunted me in my life, and I had more of an aversion to dying, and I wasn’t drawn to that end of medicine, at all,” Kerr told The News. “I kind of kept it to myself, and then I came here and I started working, and I’m basically confronted with what I had seen as a child.” 

Learning from the nurses

Like his father, Kerr became a doctor. He was a cardiology fellow in 1999 and, with two children at home, needed to moonlight to support his family. That led to him working part time at Hospice Buffalo.

After just six months at Hospice Buffalo, he decided he was there to stay.

“I got here, and the nurses were so gifted, and the social workers and the pastoral care at understanding the experience of dying from the patient's perspective, and really attuned to not just the objective things that I would look at – examination or vital signs or medications – but really what the patient’s inner world was like at this time,” Kerr said. “And they could predict very accurately when somebody was going to die.”

Kerr provides an example of that in the early pages of his book. 

In the anecdote, Kerr, still a 30-year-old cardiology fellow, examines a patient with end-stage AIDS and then informs the nurses that he thinks he can extend the patient’s time with IV antibiotics and fluids.

But the charge nurse informs Kerr that it’s too late and the patient is dying.

“He’s been dreaming about his dead mother,” the nurse tells Kerr.

Kerr chuckled awkwardly, commenting that he didn’t remember that class from medical school.

“Son,” the nurse said, “you must have missed a lot of classes.”

As Kerr observed more of these end-of-life experiences, he saw how much they mattered to patients. So as their doctor, the experiences mattered to him, too.

Studying the dying

Mary, a 70-year-old artist and mother of four, was one of Kerr’s first patients at Hospice Buffalo.

He recalls going to her room while she was being visited by family. During that visit, Mary suddenly began to hold a baby only she could see, calling him Danny.

While Kerr saw Mary in a state of bliss, her children in the room were confused and figured she must be hallucinating or reacting to medication. The children eventually became emotional in seeing their mother’s serenity. 

Answers arrived the next day when Mary’s sister visited from out of town. Before any of Mary’s four children were born, the sister explained, Mary had given birth to a stillborn baby she had named Danny. Overcome with grief, Mary had never spoken to her four children about losing Danny.

“Yet in this moment, with death waiting in the wings, the experience of new life had returned to Mary in a manner that clearly provided warmth and love, and maybe even some small compensation for her loss,” Kerr wrote in his book.

Meeting patients like Mary is what convinced Kerr to research end-of-life experiences. He hoped studies and data would remove any doubt that predeath dreams and visions exist, and he wanted to provide the patient’s perspective on the prevalence, content and significance of the experiences.

Kerr worked with Dr. Anne Banas, then a University at Buffalo research fellow, on the research proposal. To participate, patients had to consent and understand the implications of taking part, and the document had to be read and signed in front of a witness. The study did not include patients who displayed any signs of dementia, delirium or confusion, and they also filmed the patients, aiming to beat back the notion that end-of-life experiences were the product of a confused mind. 

Through the research about end-of-life experiences, Hospice & Palliative Care Buffalo has found about 88% of patients report having at least one end-of-life experience, with almost all of them reporting that the experience seems or feels real, according to findings posted on the organization’s website. More than 60% of patients felt their dreams were comforting, while just under 19% felt the experiences were distressing.

The research team has completed several more studies, including on how end-of-life experiences affect bereaved caregivers and on the end-of-life dreams and visions of children with terminal diagnoses.

But all the work is built around a theme, Kerr said, of trying to humanize the dying process.

‘It found the right audience’

The original motivation was to convince doctors of the clinical relevance of end-of-life experiences.

But, as Kerr put it, “I was clearly holding the wrong end of the stick.”

The real audience was anyone who has to confront the loss of a loved one, which could be why it has resonated so widely.

In Kerr’s book, he writes that “end-of-life experiences testify to our greatest needs – to love and be loved, to be nurtured and feel connected, to be remembered and forgiven.” 

Doctors, he believes, owe it to their patients “to support and facilitate their capacity for self-healing and self-nurture.” All of Kerr’s patients die, but “there is light within the darkness of dying as most patients find a path to affirming the love they felt, the relationships they cherished, and the life they led,” he writes.

Kerr thinks it will be difficult to change medicine, reasoning that “dying is ultimately a human experience, not a medical paradigm to solve.”

But, he believes, the answer for improved end-of-life care is outside of medicine, in an environment that has given rise to end-of-life doulas and death cafes. The new generation doesn’t defer as much to the physician, and more people want to die at home in the company of their loved ones, he said.

“I think the culture, our society, will change how we treat the dying,” Kerr said. “So I think it found the right audience.”